Ways to pay
Set your payment up for automatic withdrawal, its fast, its secure and you won’t have to worry about late fees. Call and pay over the phone. Pay online with your carrier. Mail your payment.
ADIRONDACK INSURANCE EXCHANGE:
Agent Phone: (877) 248-0555
Insured Phone: (877) 248-8811
AMTRUST:
(877) 528-7878
BROOME CO-OPERATIVE:
(607) 321-2655
DRYDEN MUTUAL:
(800) 694-8271
ERIE & NIAGARA:
(716) 632-5433
FOREMOST:
Auto Only: 1-888-888-0080
All Other Products (Home, Mobile Home, RVs, etc.): 1-800-532-4221
LEATHERSTOCKING INSURANCE:
(607) 547-2007
LIBERTY MUTUAL:
(800) 228-7830
NATIONAL GRANGE/MAIN STREET AMERICA:
(800) 258-5310
NEW YORK MUTUAL UNDERWRITERS:
Local: (518) 783-6968
Toll Free: (800) 962-3155
NYCM:
(800) 234-6926
NYSIF:
(877) 309-6028
ONTARIO:
(585) 289-9560
PREFERRED MUTUAL:
1-800-333-764
PROGRESSIVE:
1-800. PROGRESSIVE
SAFECO:
(888) 723-3260
SELECTIVE:
(877)-348-0552
SHELTER POINT:
(800) 365-4999
TRAVELERS:
(800) 842-5075